I have been playing the game for about a week now... all I can say is WWWWOOOOOOWWWWW!!!! With all things considered (size of environment, complete controllability - except as described below, and multiple modes of AO's [area of ops]), I think the graphics are marvelous. Those that ridicule the graphics are off their rocker. I just finished HL2 and that had 5 disks and a 45min install time... sure it looked great, but still didn't even come close to the massive gaming environment that you have provided. I haven't played any of the BC series so I am coming in fresh with no knowledge of previous controls etc... I have never been a big fan of keyboard controls except for fps. However, I do like the fact that the keyboard controls still take precedent even when a joystick is used. That has allowed for customization of my joy profile with the x52.
The multiple modes of play are outstanding. space, planetside flying & vehicles, and fps -- fabulous intigration. I love the personnel tracking on the ship. I just wish I could send the marines to more places specifically, at least until the CO ai increases to a smarter level - although I'm sure that gets into other complications with the game. Still trying to get a grasp of all the control features and where the various items are located in the menus... it seems a little unorganized right now, but I am sure that the organization of it will seep in as I play more. The depth of control is still quite amazing. There seems to be an issue with the orders for support craft -- escort, defend, etc. I have read all the posts, but there should be a difference in the way the ships react to the environment with respect to those commands (i.e.: "escort" remains with the target and attacks only in close proximity to the target - ignoring distant targets; "defend" performs on a system scale, but places priority on enemy closer to the target ship) hope that made sense. I have seen that it depends on where you give the command from... why should it matter whether you give the command from the TOM or the TLM -- it's still an order from the commander.
I appreciate the way you support your game - I can't think of any of the developers out there that spend so much time in the personal aspect of monitoring the boards. ... harsh sometimes, but then again stupidity deserves to be treated in such ways. Don't know exactly how to go about it, but organizing the forums a bit might help with the information search. (ie - rules for post title corresponding with the body, no multiple questions within one post - but that takes up space, etc) I have seen some boards that work really well that way, and it helps eliminate the multiple posts that are spread from Alpha Centauri to Regulus with little tidbits of info.
I'm not a tech person when it comes to the inner program workings, but I am an old gamer from way back - enough games on my shelves to start my own store - so I can't really provide much in the way of technical criticisms.
Overall I love this game, appreciate the effort that has gone into it, and the support that the creators and the rest of the senior players put into it and the forums to keep it going.